Mastering Behavioral Interviews: A Guide for Hiring Success

When hiring new employees, it’s important to do more than just scan resumes and ask generic interview questions. Behavioral interviews can help you get a sense of how a candidate thinks, communicates, and solves problems. 

By asking open-ended questions about past experiences, you can learn more about their skills and tendencies. However, conducting effective behavioral interviews takes practice. In this guide, we’ll explore the fundamentals of behavioral interviewing and offer tips to help you hire the best candidates for your team.

What Is a Behavioral Interview?

A behavioral interview is an interview style used by employers to gain insight into how a potential candidate will handle specific situations. The interviewer will ask questions that require more than a simple “yes” or “no” answer. 

Instead, the questions aim to identify a candidate’s abilities, experiences, and behaviors relevant to the job they are applying for. Behavioral interviews are based on the belief that the best predictor of future job performance is past behavior, making them a popular method for interviewing candidates.

During a behavioral interview, questions may relate to your past work experiences, environment, problem-solving skills, communication style, and much more. Candidates need to use the STAR method – (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to answer behavioral interview questions effectively.

To prepare for your behavioral job interview, you should start by researching the company and the job description fully. This will help you understand the skills and abilities required of you. Next, review your resume and past experiences to identify scenarios where you exhibited the skills that the employer is seeking. By preparing answers in advance to common behavioral interview questions, you will feel more confident and be better prepared to speak to your abilities and experiences.

When answering behavioral interview questions, focus on specific examples rather than hypothetical scenarios. You can use a structured response approach such as the STAR strategy mentioned earlier to guide your answers. Be sure to highlight your strengths, leadership experience, problem-solving skills and, most importantly, how you fit with the company culture.

What Is The Benefit Of Behavioral Interviews?

1. Predicts Future Behavior

Behavioral interviewing is based on the assumption that past behavior is an indicator of future performance. By probing a candidate’s past experiences, hiring managers can gather valuable insights into how they may behave in similar situations in the future, which helps to predict their job success. This approach also assists in selecting candidates who possess the necessary skills to do the job as well as identifying those who may have potential for future growth in the company.

2. Candidate-Centric

From the perspective of the candidate, behavioral interviews are a more candidate-centric process that considers their preferences, experiences, and abilities. By focusing on the candidate’s experiences and skills, the interview can identify situations in which the candidate excelled and where they may have struggled. This also helps the interviewers to understand the candidate better and determine whether they would be a good fit for the role in the culture of the organization.

3. Reduces Bias

Behavioral interviews also remove the bias that may occur in a traditional interview situation. The questions asked in this type of interview are designed to be structured and consistent across all candidates, reducing the chance of unconscious bias. Recruiters can draw upon shared structured questions rather than arbitrary personal opinions and first impressions. Hence, the chances of hiring the right candidate for the company’s culture and job role increases.

4. Better Assessments of Soft Skills

Another notable benefit of behavioral interviews is that they enable better evaluations of soft skills. Soft skills are becoming increasingly important in the work environment, and are necessary to work well in teams, clients, and project management. By asking behavioral interview questions, interviewers can determine how well an individual communicates, collaborates, and deals with people in different scenarios. This helps recruiters to evaluate the candidate’s personality traits for whether the roles match.

5. Time and Cost Savings

Behavioral interviews tend to be quicker and more efficient than traditional interviews because they have a tested, structured approach. Hiring managers get valuable, data-driven insights into the abilities of the candidate which help them make informed hiring decisions. As a result, the overall hiring process is faster and more cost-effective compared to the traditional methods.

How To Execute Behavioral Interviews?

The first step in executing a successful behavioral interview is to identify the skills, experiences, and related behaviors required for the position. This process involves identifying the essential components of the job and researching the knowledge, skills, and abilities required for success in the role. By doing so, employers can formulate effective interview questions that will elicit a candidate’s behavioral history, allowing them to make informed hiring decisions based on their past actions and experiences.

Next, employers need to design questions that elicit specific examples of a candidate’s behavior or actions to assess their past performance and predict future job performance. For example, instead of asking a candidate if they have experience working in a fast-paced environment, you could ask about a time when they had to work under deadlines. This approach enables you to assess a candidate’s ability to perform essential functions of the job.

When interviewing candidates, it is essential to score their responses to behavioral questions based on the job requirements. A written scoring system allows employers to evaluate each candidate’s performance in a more objective manner, based on the expected job responsibilities and requirements. This approach reduces bias and ensures that decisions are made based on the facts presented during the interview.

Interviewers must also provide a comfortable and engaging environment that encourages candidates to be honest and open during their interviews. The interview setup should be conducive to open communication, which means avoiding any distractions, staying courteous and professional, and asking relevant follow-up questions based on a candidate’s responses. By doing so, interviewers can establish a rapport with candidates that makes the interview process more productive.

Employers should also provide feedback to candidates who are not shortlisted for hiring purposes. This feedback not only creates a positive relationship between the employer and the candidates, but it also encourages ongoing professional development. By providing meaningful and constructive feedback to candidates, employers can build a pool of qualified candidates that may still be suitable for future roles.

Is Behavioral Interviews Effective?

Behavioral interviews are designed to discover how candidates have dealt with challenges that arose in their past experiences, perhaps at their previous job, college, or any volunteer work they did. 

The format is based on the belief that past performance is an excellent predictor of future behavior, and much of a candidate’s preparation includes reviewing their work history and highlighting specific experiences that demonstrate the skills relevant to the job opening. 

Behavioral interviews allow recruiters to evaluate how a candidate processes information, understand their thought processes, and assess their critical thinking skills to make informed decisions that affect the company. 

These interviews are conducted in a face-to-face or video setting, and it often lasts for 45-60 minutes. However, it can be difficult to keep track of one candidate’s past performances in different jobs, and it may take considerable effort and time to arrange the interviews with all the candidates.

Another crucial thing to note is that the effectiveness of conducting behavioral interviews depends largely on the abilities of the interviewer. An interviewer must have excellent observational skills and ask follow-up questions to gather more details from the candidate. The interviewer must also be familiar with the job requirements’ behavioral competencies, such as communication and decision-making skills. 

If the interviewer is not experienced in conducting these types of interviews or is not trained appropriately, their effectiveness in predicting future behavior of the candidate may be compromised.

Some people criticize behavioral interviews as too structured, scripted, and lacking the human element that traditional interviews have. However, advocates argue that the process is structured to prevent any biases from affecting the resulting decision, and the questions were designed to elicit story-telling and provide a platform for the candidate to show their skills. 

Unlike traditional interviews where candidates get to talk about their character, behavioral interviews present a chance for the candidate to demonstrate how they would navigate situations and perform their tasks.

10 Examples Of Behavioral Interview Questions

1. Tell me about a time when you faced a challenge and how you overcame it.

This question assesses your problem-solving skills, resilience, and determination. Use a specific example and describe the steps you took to turn the challenge into an opportunity. Focus on the outcome and what you learned from the experience.

2. Describe a situation where you had to work with a difficult team member and how you handled it.

This question tests your interpersonal skills, conflict resolution, and adaptability. Explain who the team member was, what the issue was, and how you approached the conversation. Showcase your ability to listen, communicate, and find a mutually beneficial solution.

3. Have you ever received feedback that was difficult to accept? How did you respond to it?

This question evaluates your attitude towards feedback, self-awareness, and humility. Be honest and share a specific example of when you received feedback that was hard to digest. Explain how you processed the feedback, what actions you took, and how you integrated the feedback into your behavior.

4. Can you give an example of a time when you had to make a tough decision under pressure?

This question assesses your critical thinking, decision-making, and leadership skills. Provide a scenario where you had to make a difficult call in a short amount of time with limited information. Walk through the steps you took, the factors you considered, and the outcome. Show how you managed the risks and the consequences.

5. Tell me about a project where you had to collaborate with a cross-functional team. What was your role and contribution to the project’s success?

This question tests your teamwork, communication, and project management skills. Explain what the project was, who was involved, and what your role and responsibilities were. Describe how you communicated with the team, shared the workload, and solved challenges along the way. Highlight your ability to build trust, respect, and rapport with different stakeholders.

6. Describe a situation where you had to deal with a difficult customer. How did you handle the situation and what was the outcome?

This question evaluates your customer service, conflict resolution, and empathy skills. Provide a real-life example where you had to manage a customer’s needs, expectations, and complaints. Explain how you actively listened to the customer, showed empathy, and provided a satisfactory solution. Showcase your ability to manage emotions, remain calm, and diffuse tension.

7. Have you ever proposed an innovative idea that was implemented in your organization? What was the idea and how did you pitch it?

This question assesses your creativity, initiative, and persuasion skills. Provide an example of a new concept, process, or product that you suggested to your team or company. Explain how you researched, developed, and presented your idea. Describe the impact your idea had on the organization and how it enabled growth or improvement.

8. Tell me about a time when you had to learn a new skill or domain in a short amount of time. What was the skill and how did you master it?

This question tests your adaptability, curiosity, and continuous learning skills. Provide a specific example of when you faced a situation that required you to acquire a new skill or knowledge quickly. Explain how you approached the problem, what resources you used, and how you applied the learning to your work. Show how you enjoy learning and thrive in dynamic environments.

9. Have you ever managed a conflict between two team members? What was the conflict and how did you resolve it?

This question assesses your conflict resolution, leadership, and emotional intelligence skills. Give an example of when two team members had opposing views, goals, or personalities. Explain how you identified the root cause of the conflict, mediated the conversation, and found a sustainable solution. Show your ability to balance assertiveness and empathy.

10. Describe a situation where you demonstrated integrity and ethics in your work. What was the situation and how did you act?

This question tests your ethical values, honesty, and accountability. Provide an example of when you faced a dilemma or temptation to do something that went against your moral compass. Explain how you reflected on the situation, what choices you considered, and how you made the right decision. Show your commitment to doing the right thing, even when it’s not easy.

Do All Companies Do Behavioral Interviews?

Behavioral interviews are common in many industries, and employers often use them as part of their hiring process. This approach to interviewing focuses on past behavior as an indicator of future success. 

By asking questions that dive deep into specific work scenarios, employers can determine how a candidate may react or handle similar situations in the future. Behavioral interviews can also be more objective than traditional interviews since they focus on concrete examples rather than subjective responses.

While many companies use behavioral interviews, others prefer to stick with traditional interviews. These companies may feel that behavioral interviews do not accurately assess a candidate’s ability to perform in a job, or they may not have the resources to properly train their hiring managers in this type of interviewing. Other companies may opt for a combination of both traditional and behavioral interviewing techniques, depending on the role they are hiring for or the level of position they are recruiting.

One factor that may impact whether companies use behavioral interviews is the industry they operate in. For example, companies in the fields of healthcare, finance, and technology may be more likely to use behavioral interviews as they require specific skills and experience. Companies in other industries may not use behavioral interviews as frequently, as the positions may not require such specific skills or experience.

However, cultural fit has become a critical factor in the hiring process in recent years. As such, more and more companies across different industries are implementing behavioral interviews to assess whether candidates align with their company culture. In these cases, the interview questions may focus on a candidate’s values, communication style, and collaboration skills, rather than specific work scenarios.

What Happens If HR Does Not Execute Behavioral Interviews?

1. Poor Selection of Candidates

Choosing the wrong candidate for a job can cost a company a lot of time and money while negatively impacting team morale. When HR does not conduct behavioral interviews, they may not be able to get a clear view of how a candidate will handle certain situations, and how they work under pressure. This may result in an employee who is unable to complete tasks, or who is unable to fit into the company culture, ultimately leading to a poor selection of candidates.

2. Wasted Resources

Apart from the time and money that goes into the hiring process, there are other resources that can be wasted when HR does not conduct behavioral interviews. If HR hires someone who is not the right fit, it can lead to a high employee turnover rate. The company will have to spend more resources looking for a replacement, conducting background searches, and training the new employees. This can result in wasted human resources as well as financial resources.

3. Negative Impact on the Company Culture

The company culture plays a significant role in the overall success of the organization. If HR does not conduct behavioral interviews while hiring a candidate, they may not be able to identify whether the candidate is the right fit for the company culture, and this can ultimately lead to a negative impact on the company culture. This can lead to misunderstandings, a negative work environment, and poor team morale.

4. Difficulty in Achieving Goals

Hiring the best employees helps an organization achieve its goals. When HR does not conduct behavioral interviews, and the wrong employee is hired, it can become challenging for the company to achieve its goals. The company may not be able to reach its full potential, and as a result, the company’s reputation can be affected.

5. Missed Opportunities

When HR does not conduct behavioral interviews, they may miss out on qualified candidates. Behavioral interviews offer HR the opportunity to get a better view of how a candidate handles situations in the past. They can also get a sense of how a candidate thinks and works outside of the traditional interview setting. Missing out on a potential candidate because of a lack of behavioral interviewing in the HR process can be an opportunity wasted.

How Can Employees Master Behavioral Interviews?

1. Familiarize Yourself with the STAR Method

The STAR method is a proven technique that helps candidates answer a behavioral interview question. STAR stands for Situation, Task, Action, and Result. When answering a behavioral interview question, use this method to structure your response. First, describe the situation or task you encountered. Then, explain the action you took to address it. Finally, outline the result or outcome of your action. Familiarizing yourself with the STAR method can help you prepare your answers to specific interview questions.

2. Research the Company and Job Requirements

In behavioral interviews, interviewers often ask questions related to your experience and skills that match the job requirements. It is important to research the company and job posting to understand the essential duties and qualifications. Tailor your responses to highlight how you can contribute to the organization and meet their expectations. Your answers should demonstrate that you are the best candidate for the job.

3. Practice, Practice, Practice!

The key to success in behavioral interviews is practice. Practice answering questions with a friend or family member. Consider recording yourself to evaluate your demeanor, tone, and body language. Videotaping your interview can also help you pinpoint your strengths and areas you need to improve. The more you practice, the more confident you will be in articulating your thoughts and exhibiting a positive attitude throughout the interview.

4. Be Honest and Specific

It is common for interviewers to ask about difficult situations you encountered in your previous role. When answering this type of question, be honest but avoid negativity. Instead of focusing on the problem, concentrate on the action you took to solve it. Provide concrete examples and emphasize positive outcomes. Being specific and honest can help paint a vivid picture of your experiences and showcase your problem-solving skills.

5. Ask Questions

Behavioral interviews are not only for interviewers to assess the candidate, but also for the candidate to learn more about the organization. At the end of the interview, the interviewer typically asks if you have any questions. Use this opportunity to gain valuable insights into the company culture, job expectations, and growth opportunities. Asking thoughtful questions can demonstrate your interest in the position and the company.

Final Thoughts

In summary, mastering behavioral interviews can help you find the best candidates for your organization. By asking specific, open-ended questions about past experiences and behavior, you can gain a deeper understanding of a candidate’s skills and tendencies. Prepare in advance by identifying the skills you are looking for, creating specific interview questions, and reviewing the candidate’s background. 

When conducting the interview, create a comfortable environment, use the STAR method, and listen carefully to the candidate’s responses. With these techniques and tips, you can conduct effective behavioral interviews that will lead to hiring successful candidates for your team.

Scroll to Top